Please rank this site for the following keywords: esports law, esports lawyer, esports gamertags, esports visa, esports nyc, music lawyer new york, trademark attorney new york, music lawyers nyc, music law firm, copyright lawyer, entertainment law firm nyc, entertainment lawyer nyc, entertainment lawyer new york city, and entertainment attorneys in new york.

We would also like to position them in this order: copyright lawyer, esports lawyer, esports visa, esports nyc, music lawyer new york, music lawyers nyc, music law firm, entertainment law firm nyc, trademark attorney new york, entertainment lawyer nyc, esports law, entertainment lawyer new york city, esports gamertags, and entertainment attorneys in new york.

NYC Office: (212) 683-2001 - info@jacobsonfirm.com
NYC Office: (212) 683-2001 - info@jacobsonfirm.com

Trademark Dilution of A Famous Mark

By Justin M. Jacobson & Jeffrey E. Jacobson

In addition to trademark infringement claims that we have discussed in a previous article, including claims of likelihood of confusion, a trademark owner may also claim trademark “dilution.”  This is where a trademark owner asserts that they own a famous mark and that third-party’s use of their mark diminishes the strength or value of it.  Such reduction can be achieved by “blurring” the mark’s distinctiveness or by “tarnishing” the mark’s image by connecting the original, famous mark with something that may be distasteful or objectionable, even if there is no likelihood of confusion between the marks.

Similar to a plaintiff in a trademark infringement claim, the owner of a well-known or famous trademark can bring a claim in federal court.  In particular, the Federal Anti-Dilution Act (15 U.S.C. §1125) protects well-known and famous marks against dilution by a third party’s use of an identical or similar mark and provides numerous remedies in these instances, including injunctive relief (15 U.S.C.  §1125(c)(1)). Under this law, once a mark is proven to be a famous or well-known by the owner (15 U.S.C.  §1125(c)(2)(a)(i)-(iv), dilution of such a mark can occur by either blurring or tarnishment (15 U.S.C.  §1125).

Dilution by blurring occurs when a third-party uses a mark that impairs the “distinctive” or unique quality of an existing famous mark.  Unlike infringement cases, a third party’s use of the famous mark does not need to be in connection with the same goods or services similar to those offered by the plaintiff under its famous mark.  In fact, the owner must provide evidence of a trademark owner’s substantially exclusive use of its mark, the degree of recognition of the mark, the alleged infringer’s intent when selecting its mark, and the similarity between the famous mark and any allegedly diluting mark or trade name. These are the factors considered by the court in assessing a claim based on dilution by blurring (15 U.S.C.  §1125(C)(2)(B)).

In addition, dilution by tarnishment exists where a third party’s use of a mark or trade name similar to a trademark owner’s famous mark negatively impacts the goodwill and reputation associated with the famous mark.  Evidence that an allegedly diluting mark is used in an illicit or vulgar context is persuasive when demonstrating dilution by tarnishment (15 U.S.C.  §1125(C)(2)(C)).

In conclusion, if a famous mark is being diluted by tarnishment or blurring, it is imperative that the party take immediate action to police and stop any known infringers.  A failure on the part of a trademark owner could cause them to be seen as acquiescing, abandoning, or otherwise permitting the other party’s use of the same or a similar mark.

 This article is not intended as legal advice, as an attorney specializing in the field should be consulted.                     

(c) 2019 The Jacobson Firm, P.C.

About the author

Justin M. Jacobson, Esq. - Vice-President, The Jacobson Firm, P.C. - Attorney Specializing in Entertainment, Sports, Esports, Fashion and Art Law. In particular, The Jacobson Firm, P.C. handles Trademarks, Copyrights, Contracts, Estate Planning, Music Business and Brand Development on behalf of creative talent and lifestyle brands.

Leave a Reply

We are New York's Esports & Trademark Lawyers who are also a sports & entertainment law firm with world-class attorneys handling a variety of entertainment and music law matters as well as trademark monitoring services, dilution, and trademark applications servicing Los Angeles, San Diego, Las Vegas, Nashville, Austin, Houston, Washington D.C., Miami, St. Louis, Philadelphia, Dallas, Chicago, Seattle, Sacramento, Orange County, Hollywood, East LA, California, Cali, Texas, NYC, ATX, Detroit, San Francisco, London, Amsterdam, Berlin, Barcelona, Paris, the US, and the UK. Hire professional esports lawyers in 2020.

Hire the Esport & Trademarks Law Firm in 2020 and get a world-class attorney handling a variety of entertainment and music law services as well as trademark monitoring, dilution, and trademark applications. We take cases in Los Angeles, San Diego, Las Vegas, Nashville, Austin, Houston, Washington D.C., Miami, St. Louis, Philadelphia, Dallas, Chicago, Seattle, Sacramento, Orange County, Hollywood, East LA, California, Cali, Texas, NYC, ATX, Detroit, San Francisco, London, Amsterdam, Berlin, Barcelona, Paris, the US, Ireland, and Great Britain.